Central Ohio

There are more than 256 insurance-related companies in Ohio. Below is a list of companies, as well as several agencies, with a presence in Central Ohio. Please note that organizations within a region are subject to change.

AAA Automobile Club Insurance Agency Inc. 

Accelerated Benefits 

Aetna Better Health Inc. 

  • Address: 7400 West Campus Road, New Albany, OH, 43054
  • Website

Allied Insurance Company of America 

  • Address: One West Nationwide Boulevard 1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page

American Family Insurance

  • Address: 1900 Polaris Parkway, Suite 200A, Columbus, OH, 43240-4037
  • Website
  • Career Page

American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation 

  • Address: 5656 Frantz Road, Dublin, OH, 43017

Associated Insurance Agencies Inc. 

  • Address: 63 Commerce Park Drive, Westerville, OH, 43082
  • Website

Benchmark Insurance Inc. 

  • Address: 111 Hoff Road, Westerville, OH, 43082
  • Website

Best Hoovler McTeague Insurance 

  • Address: 540 Officenter Place, Suite 180, Gahanna, OH, 43230
  • Website

Brower Insurance Agency LLC

Buckeye Community Health Plan Inc. 

Catholic Ladies of Columbia 

CareSource

Catamaran Insurance of Ohio, Inc. 

  • Address: 4400 Easton Commons Way Suite 125, Columbus, OH, 43219

CBIZ Benefits & Insurance Services of Ohio 

Century Surety Company 

Club Insurance Company 

  • Address: 90 East Wilson Bridge Road, Worthington, OH, 430852325

Cooperative Group Benefits Plan

  • Address: 4789 Rings Road, Dublin, OH, 43017

Crestbrook Insurance Company 

  • Address: One West Nationwide Boulevard 1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page

Crotty & Associates, LLC.  

  • Address: 6077 Frantz Raod, Suite 203, Dublin, OH, 43017
  • Website

Dawson Insurance Inc. / Group Benefits Agency

Dealers Assurance Company

  • Address: 3518 Riverside Drive, Upper Arlington, OH, 43221
  • Website

Delta Dental Plan of Ohio Inc.

Erie Insurance

Excess Share Insurance Corporation

  • Address: 5656 Frantz Road, Dublin, OH, 43017
  • Website

Farmers Insurance of Columbus Inc.

The Farmers Mutual Relief Association  

  • Address: 247 Tarhe Trail  Box 239, Upper Sandusky, OH, 433510239
  • Website

Fireman's Fund Insurance Company of Ohio 

Franchise Insurance Agency Inc. 

  • Address: 4942 Reed Road, Columbus, OH, 43220
  • Website 

Freedom Specialty Insurance Company

  •  Address: One W Natiownide Blvd   1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website 

Gardiner Allent DeRoberts Insurance, LLC

  • Address: 777 Goodale Boulevard, Suite 200, Columbus, OH, 43212
  • Website

Grange Indemnity Insurance Company

  • Address: 671 S. High Street, Columbus, OH, 432161218
  • Website

Grange Insurance Company of Michigan 

  • Address: 671 S. High Street, Columbus, OH, 432161218
  • Website

Grange Life Insurance Company 

  • Address: 671 S. High Street, Columbus, OH, 432161212
  • Website

Grange Mutual Casualty Company 

  • Address: 671 S. High Street, Columbus, OH, 432061014
  • Website

Grange Property & Casualty Insurance Company 

  • Address: 671 S. High Street, Columbus, OH, 432161218
  • Website

Hallmark National Insurance Company 

  • Address: 518 E Broad Street, Columbus, OH, 43215
  • Website

Haughn & Associates, Inc.

Healthcare Underwriters Group Mutual of Ohio 

  • Address: 450 Alkyre Run Road, Suite 360, Westerville, OH, 43082
  • Website

Hummel & Plum Insurance Agency Inc.

  • Address: 116 West Franklin Street, Circleville, OH, 43113
  • Website

Huntington Insurance 

  • Address: 7 Easton Oval, Columbus, OH, 43219
  • Website

Hylant Group Inc. 

Jim Barton & Associates, Inc. 

  • Address: 945 River Road, Granville, OH, 43023
  • Website

John Dawson Associates 

  • Address: 6025 Cleveland Avenue, Columbus, OH, 43231
  • Website 

Leaver Insurance Agency 

  • Address: 6059 Frantz Road, Suite 105, Dublin, OH, 43017
  • Website

MAPFRE Insurance

McCormick & Reinmuth Insurance Agency 

  • Address: 6649 North High Street, Worthington, OH, 43085
  • Website

Medical Benefits Mutual Life Insurance Company 

  • Address: 1975 Tamarack Road, Newark, OH, 43055
  • Website

Mico Insurance Company 

  • Address: 471 East Broad Street, Columbus, OH, 43215

Molina Healthcare of Ohio Inc. 

Motorists Life Insurance Company

  • Address: 471 East Broad Street, Columbus, OH, 43215
  • Website

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company

Mount Carmel Health Insurance Company 

  • Address: 6150 East Broad Street  EE320, Columbus, OH, 43213

Mount Carmel Health Plan Inc. 

  • Address: 6150 East Broad Street  EE320, Columbus, OH, 43213 

Nationwide Affinity Insurance Company of America 

Nationwide General Insurance Company 

Nationwide Indemnity Company 

Nationwide Insurance Company of Florida 

  • Address: One W Nationwide Blvd   1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page

Nationwide Life and Annuity Insurance Company 

  • Address: One W Nationwide Blvd   1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page

Nationwide Life Insurance Company 

  • Address: One W Nationwide Blvd   1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page

Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company 

  • Address: One W Nationwide Blvd   1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company 

  • Address: One W Nationwide Blvd   1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page

Nationwide Property & Casualty Insurance Company 

  • Address: One W Nationwide Blvd   1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page
Neace Lukens 

OHA Insurance Solutions Inc.

  • Address: 155 E Broad Street, Floor 2, Columbus, OH, 432153619
  • Website 

OHIC Insurance Company 

Ohio Bankers Benefits Trust 

  • Address: 4249 Easton Way, Columbus, OH, 43219 

Ohio Bar Liability Insurance Company 

  • Address: 1650 Lake Shore Drive, Columbus, OH, 432162708
  • Website

Ohio Bar Title Insurance Company 

  • Address: 8740 Orion Place, Suite 310, Columbus, OH, 43240
  • Website 

Ohio Funeral Directors Association Benefit Trust

  • Address: 2501 North Star Road, Columbus, OH, 43221
  • Website

Ohio Indemnity Company

Ohio Insurance Services Agency Inc.

  • Address: 8120 Corporate Boulevard, Plain City, OH, 43064
  • Website

Ohio Mutual Insurance Company 

The Order of United Commercial Travelers of America 

  • Address: 1801 Watermark Drive, Suite 100, Columbus, OH, 43215
  • Website

Oswald Companies 

Palmer Miller Nelson Insurance Agency Inc. 

  • Address: 3215 North High Street, PO Box 82207, Columbus, OH, 43202
  • Website 

Physicians Insurance Company of Ohio 

  •  Address: 399 Venture Drive, Suite D, Lewis Center, OH, 43035

Republic-Franklin Insurance Company 

Safe Auto Insurance Company

Scottsdale Indemnity Company 

  •  Address: One West Nationwide Boulevard   1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page

Scottsdale Insurance Company 

  • Address: One West Nationwide Boulevard   1-04-701, Columbus, OH, 432152220
  • Website
  • Career Page

Seechange Health Insurance Company 

  • Address: 4079 Executive Parkway, Westerville, OH, 43081
  • Website 

State Auto Insurance Company of Ohio

State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company 

Stonewood General Insurance Company 

  • Address: 52 East Gay Street, Columbus, OH, 43215
  • Website

Stonewood National Insurance Company

  •  Address: 52 East Gay Street, Columbus, OH, 43215
  • Website

Thomas-Fenner-Woods Agency Inc. 

  • Address: 1500 Lake Shore Drive, Suite 400, Columbus, OH, 43204
  • Website

Trustgard Insurance Company 

 United Ohio Insurance Company 

UnitedHealthCare of Ohio Inc. 

  • Address: 9200 Worthington Road  OH020-3010, Westerville, OH, 430828823
  • Website 
  • Career Page

UTICA National Insurance Company of Ohio 

Wells Fargo Insurance Services USA Inc. 

Westfield Insurance Company 

Willis of Ohio, Inc.

SHARE