Northeast Ohio

There are more than 256 insurance-related companies in Ohio. Below is a list of companies, as well as several agencies, with a presence in Northeast Ohio. Please note that organizations within a region are subject to change.

Alpha Group Agency 

  • Address: 4200 Rockside Road, Cleveland, OH, 44131
  • Website

Althans Insurance Agency Inc. 

  • Address: 543 East Washington Street, Chagrin Falls, OH, 44022
  • Website

Amer Insurance 

American Family Insurance

  • Address: 7750 Town Centre Drive, Suite 100, Broadview Heights, OH, 44147
  • Website
  • Career Page

American Select Insurance Company 

  • Address: Box 5001, Westfield Center, OH 442515001

Aon Risk Services Northeast, Inc. 

Aultcare Insurance Company 

  • Address: 2600 Sixth Street SW, Canton, OH, 44710
  • Website 

Bankers Guarantee Title and Trust Company, The

  • Address: 2872 West Market Street, Fairlawn, OH, 44333
  • Website

Bristol West Casualty Insurance Company 

Britton Galagher

  • Address: 1375 East 9th Street, Cleveland, OH, 44139
  • Website

Brunswick Companies 

CareSource

  • Address: 20800 Harvard Road Suite 300, Highland Heights, OH, 44122
  • Website 
  • Career Page

Church Agency Inc. 

  • Address: 600 East Cuyahoga Falls Avenue, Akron, OH, 44310
  • Website

Cleveland Automobile Dealers Association Group Health Plan

  • Address: 10100 Brecksville Road, Brecksville, OH, 44141 

 Consumers Life Insurance Company 

Czech Catholic Union 

  • Address: 5349 Dolloff Road, Cleveland, OH, 44127
  • Website

Dawson Company

  • Address: 2267 Village Mall Drive, P.O. Box 1368, Mansfield, OH, 44901
  • Website
  • Career Page

DRY Insurance Agency, Inc. 

  • Address: 320 Center Street, Ste. A, Chardon, OH, 44024
  • Website

Entitle Insurance Company 

  • Address: 4600 Rockside Road Suite 104, Independence, OH, 44131
  • Website 

Envision Insurance Company 

  • Address: 2181 East Aurora Road, Twinsburg, OH, 44087
  • Website

Erie Insurance

Evergreen National Indemnity Company

  •  Address: 6140 Parkland Boulevard Suite 321, Mayfield Heights, OH, 44124
  • Website

Family Heritage Life Insurance Company of America 

Fitzgibbons Arnold & Co. Agency 

  • Address: 25730 First Street, Westlake, OH, 44145
  • Website

Greater Ohio Employee Health and Welfare Fund

  • Address: c/o ASCA, Akron, OH, 443092000

Hometown Health Plan

  • Address: 100 Lillian Gish Boulevard P.O. Box 4816, Massillon, OH, 44648
  • Website
  • Career Page 

Huntington Insurance

  • Address: 925 Euclid Avenue, Suite 1990, Cleveland, OH, 44115
  • Website

Hylant Group Inc. 

  • Address: 6000 Freedom Square Drive, Suite 400, Independence, OH, 44131
  • Website
  • Career Page

Insurance Diversified Agency 

  • Address: 30285 Bruce Industrial Parkway, Suite B, Solon, OH, 44139
  • Website

Insurance Partners Agency

  • Address: 26865 Center Ridge Road, Westlake, OH, 44145
  • Website 

Insurance Systems Group Inc. 

  • Address: 4500 Rockside Road, Suite 400, Cleveland, OH, 44131
  • Website

Jones & Wenner Insurance Agency, Inc.

  • Address: 3030 West Market Street, Fairlawn, OH, 44333
  • Website

Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Ohio 

  • Address: 1001 Lakeside Avenue Suite 1200, Cleveland, OH, 441141153

Leverity Insurance Solutions

  • Address: 3737 Park East Drive, Suite 204, Beachwood, OH, 44122
  • Website

Lightning Rod Mutual Insurance Company 

  • Address: 1685 Cleveland Road, Wooster, OH, 446910036

Luce, Smith & Scott Inc. 

  • Address: 6860 West Snowville Road, Suite 110, Brecksville, OH, 44141
  • Website

Managed Dentalguard Inc. 

  • Address: 6480 Rockside Woods Boulevard South, Suite 220, Cleveland, OH, 44131

Marsh & McLennan Companies

Medical Health Insurance Corporation of Ohio 

  • Address: 2060 East 9th Street, Cleveland, OH, 441151355

Medical Mutual of Ohio 

Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company 

  • Address: 1000 South Main Street, Orrville, OH, 44667
  • Website

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company 

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company 

Mountain Laurel Assurance Company 

  • Address: Box 89490, Cleveland, OH, 441016590

National Interstate Insurance Company 

National Interstate Insurance Company of Hawaii, Inc. 

North American Swiss Alliance 

  • Address: 26777 Lorain Road, Suite 321, North Olmsted, OH, 44070

Norton Mutual Fire Association 

  • Address: 529 West Tuscarawas Avenue, Barberton, OH, 44203
  • Website 

Ohio Insurance Company 

Ohio Farmers Insurance Company 

  • Address: 1 Park Circle, Westfield Center, OH, 442515001

Ohio Motorists Life Insurance Company 

  • Address: Box 6150, Cleveland, OH, 44101

Old Guard Insurance Company

Oswald Companies

Paris and Washington Townships Home Insurance Company 

  • Address: 130 Union Avenue, Minerva, OH, 44657
  • Website

Pike Mutual Insurance Company

  • Address: 3873 Cleveland Road, Wooster, OH, 44691
  • Website

Pinkerton Insurance Agency 

  • Address: 6133 Rockside Road, Suite 402, Independence, OH, 44131
  • Website 

Progressive Advanced Insurance Company 

Progressive American Insurance Company 

Progressive Bayside Insurance Company

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company 

Progressive Choice Insurance Company 

Progressive Commercial Casualty Company 

Progressive Direct Insurance Company 

Progressive Express Insurance Company 

Progressive Gulf Insurance Company 

Progressive Hawaii Insurance Corporation 

Progressive Max Insurance Company 

Progressive Mountain Insurance Company 

Progressive Northwestern Insurance Company 

Progressive Preferred Insurance Company 

Progressive Premium Insurance Company of Illinois

Progressive Select Insurance Company 

Progressive Specialty Insurance Company 

Progressive West Insurance Company 

Schauer Group, Inc. 

  • Address: 200 Market Ave. N, Suite 100, Canton, OH 44702
  • (Satellite Office) Address: 9200 South Hills Blvd., Suite 145, Broadview Heights, OH 44147
  • Website

SeibertKeck Insurance 

  • Address: 2950 West Market Street, Akron, OH, 44333
  • Website

Sonnenberg Mutual Insurance Company 

  • Address: 1685 Cleveland Road, Wooster, OH, 446910036

Springfield Township Mutual Insurance Association 

  • Address: 13439 Woodworth Road, New Springfield, OH, 44443
  • Website 

Summa Insurance Company Inc

SummaCare Inc

The Hoffman Group 

  • Address: 2 Berea Commons, Ste. 10, Berea, OH, 44017
  • Website

The Fedeli Group

Todd Associates Inc. 

  • Address: 23825 Commerce Park Road, Beachwood, OH, 44122
  • Website

Triumphe Casualty Company 

  • Address: 3250 Interstate Drive, Richfield, OH, 44286

UDC Ohio Inc

  • Address: 661 Oaktree Boulevard, Suite 130, Cleveland, OH, 44131

United Agencies Insurance Group

  • Address: 1422 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH, 44115
  • Website

United Financial Casualty Company 

  • Address: Box 89490, Cleveland, OH, 441016490

United Transportation Union Insurance Association 

  • Address: 24950 Country Club Boulevard, Suite 340, North Olmsted, OH, 440705333
  • Website 

UnitedHealthcare of Ohio Inc

UnitedHealthcare of Ohio Inc 

Victoria Fire & Casualty Company 

Victoria National Insurance Company 

Victoria Select Insurance Company 

Victoria Specialty Insurance Company 

Washington Mutual Insurance Association 

  • Address: 3873 Cleveland Road, Wooster, OH, 44691 
  • Website

Wayne Mutual Insurance Company 

WellCare of Ohio Inc

  • Address: 6060 Rockside Woods Boulevard North, Independence, OH,44131
  • Website
  • Career Page

Western Reserve Mutual Casualty Company 

Westfield Insurance Company 

Westfield National Insurance Company 

Willis of Ohio, Inc. 

Zito Insurance Agency, Inc. 

  • Address: 1249 Smith Court, Rocky River, OH, 44116
  • Website 
SHARE